Medical Alert Device Consumer Usage Report 2020
Three of four seniors age 75+ believe they do not currently need a device; Caregivers disagree
By Jennifer L. Gaskin | Last Updated: June 30, 2020
The worldwide market for medical devices is expected to rise by nearly half over just the next five years, expanding from $6.5 billion today to $9.6 billion by 2025. And it’s little wonder why. The World Health Organization estimates that by 2050, 16 percent of the world’s population will be 65 or older, which is double today’s ratio of older adults (8 percent).
Technology like fall detection, location tracing, call assistance and care management have helped these devices grow far beyond the oft-parodied, “Help, I’ve fallen and I can’t get up,” commercial that became popular in the early 1990s. Today’s medical alert devices can come in the form of a wearable pendant, wristbands, watches, fixed standalone units and more, and as the features baked into them become even more sophisticated, the utility of medical alert systems becomes even more critical.
It’s estimated that more than 3 million American seniors own a medical alert device, and as more people age into the group, competition for customers and drive for innovation could further expand the utility of these devices. In addition, as COVID-19 reduces in-person contact between seniors and their caregivers or loved ones, there is an even stronger case for serious consideration.
To get a better sense of how and why people use medical alert devices, we surveyed more than 600 Americans aged 75 and over on a range of subjects related to these technologies. We also asked more than 500 caregivers for adults ages 70 and over about senior safety products.
- Seventy-three percent of seniors believe they do not need a medical alert device, and just eight percent do. The rest are unsure.
- Caregivers list a medical alert device as the senior safety product they’d most recommend with a third of caregivers believe the senior they care for should have one.
- Each year, one-in-four seniors age 65 and up will fall, often leading to serious injuries. Roughly 23 percent of respondents experienced a fall within the past six months.
- Most medical alert device owners use a wristwatch or pendant and wear the devices every day.
- More than eight in 10 non-users who have never had a fall said they had no need for medical alert devices.
- Forty-four percent of non-users would wear a device if they had one.
Usage Habits of Medical Device Owners
The most common type of medical alert device used by seniors was a wearable pendant, with almost two-thirds of device users employing that type of device. But our research also indicates that many medical alert customers are using more than one type of device, as another 35 percent said they used wristband or watch-style devices.
While the number of respondents who use medical alert devices was relatively evenly split between women and men (about 53 percent to 47 percent), women are far more likely than men to use pendant-style devices.
More than two in three owners of wearable medical alert devices have them on at least every day (with 40 percent having them on all the time). However, nearly one in three do not wear these devices regularly or as suggested.
Perceptions of Need & Safety
Very few seniors, just eight percent, believe they for sure need a medical alert device. A large portion are unsure and the great majority believe they do not.
Compare this to the perceptions of caregivers, who recommend a medical alert device for care recipients of ages 70 to 80 more than any other safety product, and just behind walk-in tubs for seniors ages 80 and up. It should be noted that this is not an apples-to-apples comparison since not all of the seniors surveyed necessarily have a caregiver.
Older adults who live with at least one other person are the least likely to own a medical alert device, with just eight percent of this group adopting one or more devices. Those residing in senior living communities are the group most likely to own a device, which is unsurprising considering that many senior living communities provide wearables or fixed units to all residents.
Half of the medical device users in our survey bought their devices themselves, meaning that the other half use devices purchased for them or that came with their senior living apartment or room. Combined with the above analysis, it’s clear that having the choice made for them greatly increases the chances of seniors owning medical alert devices.
Similarly, the presence of paid caregivers, including staff of senior living communities, dramatically increases the rate of device ownership. Only 10 percent of seniors who don’t have a caregiver own a medical alert device.
Almost none of the seniors in our survey rated their homes as unsafe, with a combined 97 percent rating their homes as either very or somewhat safe. Those who do own medical devices also were highly likely to say that the place where they live is safe but at a lower rate than all seniors. A combined 91 percent rated their homes as very or somewhat safe, six percentage points lower than the rate for all seniors.
While this largely tracks with data from our recent State of Caregiving and Elder Safety study, it’s also important to note that almost half of the caregivers in that study who live with the elders for whom they provide care said that the place the elder lives could be made safer, and for many families, that likely will mean purchasing one or more types of medical alert devices.
Roughly one-quarter of Americans 65 and older experience a fall in a typical year, and falls are historically the leading cause of injury death among older adults. and the risk of fall is one of the strongest driving factors not only in the features these devices offer but, according to our findings, adoption of medical alert devices by older adults.
Factors Impacting Device Adoption
More than eight in 10 of the respondents in our survey said they didn’t own any type of medical alert device, and nearly three-quarters said they don’t need one. But only about 25 percent of people said they wouldn’t wear a device even if they had one. Still, if the industry is to continue expanding, it’s clear many people will need to be converted into believers of the value of medical alert devices.
Let’s take a look at what our survey indicated are the biggest reasons why people don’t use these devices:
- Perceived lack of need: A tiny percentage of those who don’t have a medical alert device said they needed one (less than 5 percent), but it’s notable that about one in five were unsure if they could use one. Female non-users may be easier to convince, as about 30 percent of that group said they either needed a device or were unsure, compared to 20 percent of their male counterparts.
- Recent medical history: About half of all respondents said they’d never experienced a fall, but among non-users who had experienced a fall in the past six months, 13 percent said they needed a medical alert device, compared to just over 1 percent of those who’ve never had a fall. Eighty-four percent of non-users who’ve never had a fall said they don’t need a device, and about 23 percent of all users have had a fall within the past six months.
- Cost: While our data did not indicate that cost is a major factor holding back adoption of devices (about half of those who believed medical alert devices were expensive said they’d wear one if they had it), there wasn’t exactly consensus among respondents about the cost of these devices. Still, among all respondents, older adults were more likely to rate products as very or somewhat expensive (39 percent) than very or somewhat inexpensive (six percent).
The medical alert device industry has come a long way from the days of cheap-looking ads and clunky, old-fashioned devices. Brands like Bay Alarm Medical, Medical Guardian, and Lively have created sleek and technological devices. Today’s medical alert devices can live within an ecosystem of connected devices to ensure that as people age in place, they’re doing so safely. There’s no doubt that the alert device market will continue to mature right alongside the continuing aging of the U.S.
About The Senior List Research and This Report
The Senior List's research team actively studies aging in place. We publish independent content covering social, economic, political, and geographic topics for seniors. Data for this report comes from surveys conducted in May and June 2020. First, we asked more than 600 adults age 75 and up about their awareness, usage, and perception of medical alert devices. Second, we asked more than 500 adults that provide care to an adult age 70 and over detailed questions about safety products. We also used data from the World Health Organization and Washington Post.