Alexa Logo

Have an Amazon Echo speaker? Get hands-free access to 24/7 Urgent Response.

Try free for 30 days

The Best Catholic Dating Sites for Seniors in 2023

When you join a Catholic dating service for seniors, you'll be introduced to compatible singles who share your beliefs and values. Here are our top recommendations for Catholic dating sites. While not all of them are exclusive to Catholics, members can use filters to find people who share their faith.
amie-clark
Share: copied!
The Senior List is compensated when you click on the provider links listed on this page. This compensation does not impact our ratings or reviews.

Looking for love? Be sure to check out our guide to this year’s best dating sites for seniors.

The Best Catholic Dating Sites for Seniors in 2023

How We Chose Our Favorites

1. CatholicMatch - Best for Devout Catholics

CatholicMatch is the largest Catholic senior dating site.
3.9 / 5
View Plans
What We Like Most:
  • Exclusively for Catholic singles
  • Responsible for thousands of marriages
  • Over 1 million members globally
  • Free messaging

Overview

Cost

Membership Monthly Cost Total Cost
Basic Free Free
1 month $29.99 $29.99
3 months $14.99 $44.97
6 months $9.99 $59.94

Created for and run by Catholics, Catholic Match is the largest Catholic-only dating community online, helping Catholic singles connect with those who share their faith. During registration, you’re asked to fill out a survey about your personality, interests, and lifestyle. Additionally, the questionnaire asks about your activity and beliefs with regard to Catholic mass, liturgy style, the sanctity of life, marriage, the Eucharist, contraception, and premarital sex.

On a desktop or using its iOS or Google application, all members of Catholic Match are free to search and filter preferences to identify potential matches. Unfortunately, only members who are free to marry in the Catholic Church are eligible to receive matches. This makes the service more suited to serious Catholics seeking marriage partners who meet the criteria for marrying within the Church. To be free to marry in the Church, you must:

  • Be baptized in the Catholic Church.
  • Not be a member of a religious order.
  • Be the recipient of an annulment if divorced.

For those who do qualify for matches through Catholic Match, the potential partners are generated using Match Portrait®, which is a survey you complete during registration. The Match Portrait questionnaire covers important topics in which successful couples typically agree, such as values, worldview, and outlook. It also determines your personality type and characteristics.

Catholic Match’s prices are excellent compared to other dating sites, ranging from $9.99 monthly for a six-month membership to $29.99 for a one-month membership.

Pros
  • Largest Catholic-only dating community
  • Filters for important Catholic preferences
  • Free and paid dating courses
  • 40 percent of users are over 45
Cons
  • Must be eligible to marry in the Catholic Church

2. Christian Cafe - Over 2 Million Members

Christian Cafe Logo
4.5 / 5
View Plans
What We Like Most:
  • 10-day free trial, including free emails and messaging
  • Filters such as church denomination
  • Over 2 million members
  • Quick and responsive customer service

Overview

Cost

Membership Monthly Cost Total Cost
1 month $39.97 $39.97
3 months $19.99 $59.97*
6 months $16.67 $99.97*
12 months $9.99 $119.97*

*Payment is collected in one lump sum as opposed to monthly payments

Christian Cafe is a popular Christian dating site with over 2 million users, many of whom are Catholic. Perfect for Catholic seniors looking to connect with others who share their commitment to faith, Christian Cafe offers single Catholic seniors one of the most inexpensive faith-based dating experiences available online. After a free 10-day trial, memberships cost as little as $9.99 per month for a 12-month subscription.

When identifying possible matches for you, Christian Cafe’s matching algorithm takes a number of factors into account, including your preferred relationship type, your denomination, the importance of faith in your life, your age, and your location. Advanced and saved searches enable you to find even more potential romantic interests who fit highly specific criteria, such as appearance, background, and lifestyle.

Pros
  • Christian-owned and -operated
  • Over 25,000 marriages from the site
  • Deletes inactive profiles automatically
  • Offers Christian fellowship, support, and advice
Cons
  • No free membership options

3. SilverSingles - Made Just for Seniors

What We Like Most:
  • Science-backed personality test
  • Set preferences for hobbies, interests, and beliefs
  • Ample dating resources
  • Exclusive to individuals over 50

Overview

Cost

Membership Monthly Cost Total Cost
Basic Free Free
3 months $37.95 $113.85
6 months $21.95 $131.70
12 months $19.95 $239.40

SilverSingles is a fantastic dating site for Catholic seniors seeking long-term relationships with religiously compatible partners. After you join, you take a detailed survey to inform SilverSingles about your personality, hobbies, faith, ambitions, values, and ideal partner.

The lengthy questionnaire may seem intimidating, but according to past users and SilverSingles, completing it can improve your matches.

Free SilverSingles memberships only offer you the ability to receive partner suggestions, view your basic personality test results, send smiles and likes, and upload photos. While three-month premium subscriptions to SilverSingles are a bit costly at $37.95 monthly, six- and 12-month memberships are more affordable, at $29.95 and $19.95 per month. These upgraded subscriptions provide far more, such as being suggested more often as a match for others, detailed personality test results, unlimited messaging, views of visits to your profile, and up to 20 additional matches per day.

To learn more about this site, read our SilverSingles review.

Pros
  • Ability to filter by interests, personality, and lifestyle
  • Unlimited messaging with aids such as icebreakers
  • Profile makeover by an expert for $99
  • Most members are focused on serious relationships
Cons
  • Initial questionnaire is very lengthy

4. ChristianMingle - Largest Christian Dating Pool

What We Like Most:
  • Large population of seniors
  • Great security
  • Ample features with the free version
  • 15 million users

Overview

Cost

Membership Monthly Cost Total Cost
1 month $49.99 $49.99
3 months $34.99 $104.97
6 months $24.99 $149.94

About 3 out of 4 Christian Mingle users attend church weekly, proving members of this dating site tend to take their faith seriously. This makes it an ideal tool for Catholic seniors who prioritize faith in a relationship and date with the intent of finding someone to marry.

The popular website and mobile app, which is available for Spanish speakers, is specific to Christians, many of whom are Catholics. Member ages are from 18 to 75-plus. However, only 20 percent of members are 55 or over. Fortunately, on a site with over 15 million members, 20 percent still leaves a dating pool of at least 3 million people. At $24.99 per month for a six-month membership, Christian Mingle costs slightly more than the average dating site. You’ll have to decide for yourself whether you agree with the former members who say this niche community is worth a few extra dollars per month.

Since Christian Mingle doesn’t ask for as much personal information as most dating sites on this list, the profile setup is super quick. Make sure to note your Catholic faith in your information to ensure you match with potential partners who at least have similar core beliefs and values to your own.

Even with matching technology, the limited information isn’t as likely to produce quality matches as sites that gather detailed personality, interests, and background information.

To learn more about Christian dating, read our guide to the best Christian dating sites.

5. Christian Dating for Free - Budget Option

Christian Dating for Free
3.8 / 5
What We Like Most:
  • No membership fees
  • 50,000 active weekly users
  • See potential matches without signing up
  • Most members indicate a desire to build a long-term relationship

Overview

Cost

Membership Monthly Cost Total Cost
Basic/General Free Free
1 month $23.99 $23.99
3 months $12.90 $38.70
6 months $8.50 $51

ChristianCafe is an online dating site exclusive to Christian singles with over 2 million members, including many Catholics. Ideal for single Catholic seeking partners who place a high value on shared faith in their relationships, ChristianCafe’s software analyzes your profile and the detailed questionnaire you fill out at registration. It looks for similarities with other members, such as preferred relationship type, denomination, the importance of faith in your life, and location.

You can also use advanced and stored searches to find compatible matches who fit more specific criteria, such as location, physical description, background, and personal interests. ChristianCafe is one of the most affordable dating sites for Catholics, with a free 10-day trial and subscriptions starting at $9.99 a month for a year.

Bottom Line

The sites listed above are excellent places to begin your Catholic dating search, whether you're looking for a new friend or a lifelong romantic partner. With so many options available, from Catholic-specific sites to apps for all Christian denominations that are available in both English and Spanish, you're sure to find a variety of great potential partners who share your Catholic faith.

To learn more about our favorite senior dating sites, check out our helpful guides:

amie-clark
Written By
Amie Clark

Amie has been writing about senior care products and services for the last decade. She is particularly passionate about new technologies that help improve the quality of life for seniors and their families. Seeing her parents and grandparents age made Amie ask herself, “Would this be good enough for my loved ones?” In her spare time, Amie enjoys outdoor adventures and spontaneous road trips. Learn more about Amie here