Medical Guardian vs LifeFone

Our editorial team has compared each company, costs, product specs and product add-ons. Scroll down to see our recommendation.

Side-by-side comparison:

Side-by-side comparison: Medical Guardian Logo LifeFone
Editor's Rating
4.8 / 5 stars
4.3 / 5 stars
4.5 / 5
4.4 / 5
Price Range$29.95 - $49.95/mo$29.95 - $47.95/mo
Up-front costsNoNo
Contract RequiredNoNo
Return PolicyStandardStandard
Product OptionsIn-home traditional, in-home cellular, cellular +GPS, smartwatchin-home traditional and cellular, cellular, cellular + GPS
Battery Life24 hours24 hours
In-home Ranges1300 ft1300 ft
Water-safe Optionspendants are waterproof, cellular units are notpendants are waterproof, cellular unit is water resistant
Fall Detection$10/mo$5/mo
Smart Watch$99 + $44.95/moNo
Spouse Monitoring$2/moFree
Phone Number*800-520-5889(866) 790-3741
Website View Website
View Website

*We recommend calling because representatives can sometimes offer special deals or pricing. We make every effort to provide and maintain accurate information on our site. However, the businesses reviewed on our site may periodically change their pricing, equipment, and packages and there may be a lag between the time they make such changes and the time we become aware of such changes. If you identify any outdated or inaccurate information, please contact us here.

Editors Recommendation

Generally, we recommend Medical Guardian over LifeFone for their latest cellular offering as well as the unique smartwatch option. However LifeFone may be a better fit if you are looking for slightly lower monthly fees or need coverage for a spouse.

Medical Guardian and LifeFone are both popular choices in terms of medical alert systems. Both are easy to use and offer a wide variety of features that provide both convenience and a heightened level of security. Both companies offer seniors a chance to live independently for as long as possible while improving their quality of life and giving them the peace of mind they are looking for.

Medical Guardian vs LifeFone Differences

While Medical Guardian has one of the best reputations for efficiency in terms of their call centers and their devices, LifeFone offers those things as well as medication reminders, environmental alerts (smoke, carbon monoxide, and fire), and smartphone apps that allow you to remain connected to your loved one no matter where they may be. Medical Guardian's call center is Five Diamond certified while LifeFone's center is not.

LifeFone vs Medical Guardian Similarities

Medical Guardian and LifeFone both provide quality services and extremely durable devices. Each company offers multiple packages and price points that allow subscribers to choose the services and devices that best suit their needs. Both offer optional fall detection and have wireless systems that use a cellular platform for reliability and convenience. Both also offer landline options for subscribers. All devices are UL Certified and wearables are waterproof so they can be worn in the shower. Both companies also offer discounts to veterans as well as members of AARP.


Medical Guardian offers a 1300 foot range with their Classic Guardian system. Coverage is available for both in the home and when you are away. Optional fall detection is available with certain packages. One of the newest devices is a SmartWatch that offers an emergency SOS button and text to speech messaging system. Both pendants and wristbands are also available.

LifeFone offers fall detection with many of their packages in addition to smartphone apps and two-way voice communication. Medication reminders and fall detection options are also available. Seniors have the choice between wall mounted devices, pendants, or wristbands. In-home systems have up to 1300 foot range. They also offer environmental alerts for fire, smoke, and carbon monoxide.

Systems & Devices

Medical Guardian offers wearable pendants and wristbands that are waterproof and extremely durable. They are now offering a SmartWatch with multiple features over and above what is normally considered for a medical alert system. All of the devices provided by Medical Guardian are UL Certified and carry a lifetime guarantee. There is a $5 replacement fee, however, on certain devices. The system tests itself on a monthly basis and reports to the monitoring center. Batteries last anywhere from 3 to 5 years and provide 32 hours of backup power.

LifeFone offers pendants, wristbands, and wall mount devices. Wearables are waterproof with all devices being UL Certified. The system performs monthly tests with results being sent to the monitoring center. Batteries are reported to last up to 5 years. You will be notified by LifeFone when it's time for a new battery. Free replacements will be sent to your home. Batteries carry approximately 32 hours of backup power.

Costs & Contracts

Medical Guardian has six plans that offer a variety of features for affordable prices. The Classic Guardian is $29.95 per month/no activation fee. The Home Guardian runs $34.95 per month/no activation fee. The Mobile Guardian costs $39.95 a month/no activation fee. The Active Guardian runs $49.95 per month with no activation fee. The Active Guardian rounds out their traditional plans costing $79.95 per month with no activation fee. The newest offering, Freedom Guardian, features the SmartWatch. It costs $44.95 per month and has a $99 activation fee. Equipment is free if you sign the 3-month service agreement.

LifeFone offers five primary packages starting with the At-Home Landline system that starts at $29.95 per month. If you pay be the quarter or annually, the prices will drop. The At-Home Cellular system costs $34.95 a month, with lower prices for paying by the year. Both At-Home packages can include Fall Detection for $5 per month. The At-Home & On-the-Go GPS costs $39.95 per month, while the At-Home & On-the-Go GPS, Voice in Pendant package costs $46.95 per month. Both of these plans will also offer lower prices if paid by the year. It costs an additional $10 per month to add Fall Detection to these two plans. The final package option is LifeFone's Complete Home Package which is billed by the year for $42.95 per month.

Emergency Response & Call Centers

Medical Guardian's emergency response time is less than 45 seconds. Call centers are not owned by Medical Guardian but are Five Diamond Certified by TMA (CSAA). They provide 24-hour emergency connectivity and will notify family members on the subscriber's contact list if an emergency is reported.

LifeFone's emergency response time is less than 1 minute. Their call center is not certified but provides effective 24-hour emergency response when an alert is reported.

Our Conclusion

Medical Guardian has a reputation for being extremely reliable and offers the security of a Five Diamond Certified call center. It's a great choice if you want maximum convenience with reliable service.

LifeFone is also extremely reliable but is often a better choice if more than one person needs service. They cover spouses without charging an additional fee.

  • Was this Helpful ?
  • yes   no