close

Medical Guardian vs Medical Care Alert

Our experts put these affordable medical alert systems side-by-side. Both deliver a variety of plans and A+ service. See which one we recommend.

Side-by-side comparison:

Side-by-side comparison: Medical Guardian Logo Medical Care Alert offers medical alert systems to seniors.
Editor's Rating
4.8 / 5 stars
3.5 / 5 stars
Company
Reputation
4.5 / 5
4.3 / 5
Costs
Price Range$29.95 - $49.95/mo$29.95 - $39.95/mo
Upfront CostsNoNo
Contract RequiredNoNo
Return PolicyStandardStandard
Product
Product OptionsIn-home traditional & cellular, mobile + GPS, smartwatchIn-home traditional & cellular, mobile + GPS
Battery Life24 hours4 days
In-home Ranges1300 ft1000 ft
Water-safe OptionsYesYes
Add-Ons
Fall Detection$10/mo$10/mo
GPSYesYes
Smart Watch$99 + $44.95/moNo
Spouse Monitoring$2/moFree for spouse
Contact
Phone Number*800-520-5889
Website View Website
 

*We recommend calling because representatives can sometimes offer special deals or pricing. We make every effort to provide and maintain accurate information on our site. However, the businesses reviewed on our site may periodically change their pricing, equipment, and packages and there may be a lag between the time they make such changes and the time we become aware of such changes. If you identify any outdated or inaccurate information, please contact us here.

Editors Recommendation

Generally, we recommend Medical Guardian over Medical Care Alert as they have a larger range on the in-home medical alert system and offer one of the first medical alert smartwatches. Both companies use well-known and highly regarded equipment. However, Medical Care Alert offers free spouse monitoring.

Medical Guardian and Medical Care Alert systems offer easy to use equipment and a variety of features that allow you to feel protected whether you are at home or away. Both offer professional monitoring and lifetime warranties on all of their equipment. Each company has achieved an A+ rating with the Better Business Bureau and continually strives to meet or exceed industry standards.

Medical Guardian vs Medical Care Alert Differences

Medical Guardian and Medical Care Alert have a few significant differences. They differ in both contracts and pricing as well as how their systems are set up and the range that can be achieved with each device. Their money back guarantees are also different with Medical Care Alert offering a 30-day risk-free trial. Medical Guardian supports over 200 different languages. Medical Care Alert only offers English and Spanish.

Medical Care Alert vs Medical Guardian Similarities

Medical Guardian and Medical Care Alert systems offer a variety of plans with affordable pricing. All of the devices offered by Medical Guardian and Medical Care Alert systems are covered by lifetime warranties. The coverage for both companies includes at home and on-the-go service. Pendants, wristbands, and clip-on devices are offered by each company. Devices are waterproof and extremely durable.

Features

Medical Guardian offers multiple devices including pendants, bracelet, and a lockbox. A medical history card is included with the lockbox feature. The monitoring center is staffed with professionals who can assist subscribers in a variety of emergency situations. Medical Guardian offers coverage both in the home and on-the-go that allows for uninterrupted peace of mind. All of their equipment comes with a lifetime warranty.

Medical Care Alert devices allow for 1000 feet from the base station. They offer an extender that increases the range by 600 feet when you go outside of your home. Fall detection can be added for an extra $10 per month. The professional monitoring center operates 24 hours a day, every day of the year. SMS texts are sent to family members if an alert is received by the call center staff.

Systems & Devices

Medical Guardian offers multiple devices including pendants, bracelet, and a lockbox. A medical history card is included with the lockbox feature. The monitoring center is staffed with professionals who can assist subscribers in a variety of emergency situations. Medical Guardian offers coverage both in the home and on-the-go that allows for uninterrupted peace of mind. All of their equipment comes with a lifetime warranty.

Medical Care Alert devices allow for 1000 feet from the base station. They offer an extender that increases the range by 600 feet when you go outside of your home. Fall detection can be added for an extra $10 per month. The professional monitoring center operates 24 hours a day, every day of the year. SMS texts are sent to family members if an alert is received by the call center staff.

Costs & Contracts

Instead of a long-term contract, Medical Guardian requires a 3-month service agreement. They offer multiple packages that include the Classic Guardian for $29.95 per month. The Home Guardian is available for $34.95 a month. The Active Guardian is the most expensive and costs $49.95 a month. The Mobile Guardian plan is for those who are on the go and costs $39.95 a month.

Medical Care Alert does not require a contract but offers packages that can be paid for by the month, quarter, semi-annually or by the year. The packages include the Home package for $29.95 a month, the Home and Yard for $34.95 a month, and the Home and Away Elite for $39.95 per month. Prices are lower if you pay be the quarter, semi-annually or by the year. Fall detection is also available for an additional $10 per month.

Emergency Response & Call Centers

Medical Guardian requires a landline for the base unit but all of the devices use cellular service. All the mobile units have GPS capabilities. Phone calls and texts are used to notify the subscriber's family if an alert is triggered. The monitoring service is Five Diamond Certified and has a response time of approximately 45 seconds or less.

The Medical Care Alert system is 100% wireless and uses cellular service for emergency connectivity. Operators at the call center are EMD/EMT-certified and have a minimum of two years of military service or college education.

Our Conclusion

Medical Guardian is one of the highest rated companies in terms of medical alert system and fast response times. It's a great choice for someone who wants reliable service and high-quality devices.

Medical Care Alert is a good choice for anyone who wants affordable service and multiple plans to choose from. Their devices are reliable and extremely easy to use.

  • Was this Helpful ?
  • yes   no