Compare Medical Alert System Companies

There are a variety of medical alert systems to choose from that vary from one company to another company, and features that vary from one medical alert system to another option. How do seniors or their loved ones determine which medical alert system is the best option?

Comparing medical alert systems, and their features, likely helps seniors decide which system is ideal for their needs.

Making Initial Comparisons

When seniors search for a medical alert system, the result is possibly a wealth of information, and confusion about which is the best system. How do you narrow the options, and find the ideal medical alert system for your needs?

Determine the features based on what is important to you. Are you mainly a homebody that primarily needs a base unit medical alert system that helps you feel safe and secure in and around your home, or are you an active senior that needs a mobile or pendant option?

Compare the systems and options, and discover some features that you possibly did not know about when considering medical alert systems.

Fall Detection

The National Council on Aging reports that falls are the number one cause of both fatal and non-fatal injuries among seniors in the United States. When a senior falls, or fears falling, there is an impact on that seniors’ quality of life.

Purchasing a medical alert system that offers fall detection potentially reduces that fear, and results in seniors feeling safer at home and outside the home. One of the most important aspects of an ideal medical alert system for seniors is likely that the company offers fall detection.

The cost of a wearable fall detection pendant is a nominal charge, typically around $10 per month.

Price Range

Do you have a price range? Do not choose the first medical alert system that you review.

Costs vary considerably among some medical alert systems. Search for a system that offers features that are important to you, and in your target price range.

No Contract

Medical alert system costs are often of importance to seniors, particularly those on a fixed budget. The cost of a medical alert system depends on several factors, including the type of system that you choose, and the costs associated with contracts.

When a company offers no contracts, this gives seniors an opportunity to save over the costs of other systems that require a contract.

Contracts typically range from several months to up to 24 months. That means that if you decide that you do not want the medical alert system anymore, or perhaps you or your loved one move to a senior living facility, you are still legally liable for all costs for the duration of the contract.

Choosing a no contract option provides a sense of freedom.

Free Activation

Medical alert system costs are likely expensive for some seniors, and saving money is likely an important selling point. There are several things to look for related to savings, including whether the company offers free activation. When you choose a medical alert system with free activation, you save on initial costs.

Some companies do not offer free activation, meaning that seniors pay the activation fees along with the costs of the medical alert system and initial monthly fees, such as monthly monitoring.

Large In-Home Range

The range of a medical alert system is likely important for many seniors. If you are a senior that wants a base unit inside the home that offers a large in-home range so that you are safe anywhere in your home, and perhaps on the front porch or gardening outside, select a medical alert system that offers a larger in-home range.

Some landline systems have a range of up to 1500 feet, while others have a moderate range of around 600 feet. Make sure that you compare the range before you buy your new medical alert system.


Many seniors still drive and own their own car. Seniors today often do their own shopping, travel to see loved ones or friends, walk or perform other exercise activities, and engage in social activities, rather than sitting at home and waiting for someone to take them somewhere.

Some medical alert systems offer GPS monitoring, an important feature for some seniors. If you are a senior that ventures outside the home, look for a medical alert system that offers GPS monitoring.

GPS location and detection tracking likely provides peace of mind for active seniors, and their loved ones.

Long Cellular Battery Life

Seniors that have a cellular medical alert system need a system that features a long battery life.

Compare the battery life of cellular options from the various providers that offer cellular-operated medical alert systems. The battery life of some systems is up to 24 hours, while the battery of other systems extend far beyond that, including some that do not need charging.

Smart Watch Option

While having a Smart Watch that also acts as a medical alert system is of less importance to some seniors, for others, it is an important option. Smart Watch medical alert system options vary the same as other medical alert systems.

Look for a smart watch functioning system that meets your needs. Smart watches offer fall detection, location pinpointing, monitoring service, and other medical alert features.

Is telling time the only additional feature that you need in your medical alert system smart watch, or do you prefer one that monitors health-related functions such as your heart rate? Some smart watch options include the ability to communicate with others, step functioning, and an attractive look.

Spouse Monitoring

Some seniors feel safer and more confident about being alone when their medical alert system features spouse monitoring.

If this is important to you, ask the companies about spouse monitoring if you do not see this as an option in the company online medical alert system description.

Compare Reviews

Some seniors give little weight to comparing reviews, while others likely consider customer reviews as an important aspect of deciding which medical alert system is ideal for them. Check reviews from reliable review sites. Some examples are the Better Business Bureau, and Consumer Reports.

Medical alert systems offer a variety of features that vary from one company to another company and from one system or style of system to another system. Choosing an ideal medical alert system is a personal decision based on your individual needs.

Summary of Medical Alert System Comparisons

We compared the top medical alert companies and products side-by-side. Click on the links to compare the best medical alert systems, medical alerts for men, alert systems with fall detection and in-home medical alert systems that do not require a landline.


  • Alert1 vs Life Alert – Longstanding medical alert systems, but only one offers month-to-month pricing options.

Bay Alarm Medical

  • Bay Alarm Medical vs GreatCall – Bay Alarm Medical offers in-home and cellular options. Do they live up to the GreatCall all-in-one?
  • Bay Alarm Medical vs Life Alert – One of these is much more transparent with pricing and contracts.
  • Bay Alarm Medical vs Medical Guardian – Both companies offer similar medical alert options, see which one is the best value with our comparison.
  • Bay Alarm Medical vs MobileHelp – Top rated medical alerts go head-to-head in this comparison. Which one is best?


  • GreatCall vs Bay Alarm Medical – How does the GreatCall Lively match up to Bay Alarm's cellular option? One of these is a clear winner.
  • GreatCall vs Life Alert – GreatCall offers month-to-month pricing while Life Alert does not. Do these two have anything in common?
  • GreatCall vs MobileHelp – All-in-one cellular vs in-home and cellular options. Are more options better or is it best to stick with an all-in-one that can cover you anywhere?

Life Alert

  • Life Alert vs Alert1 – These two longstanding medical alert companies offer vastly different products and pricing. See the details in our comparison.
  • Life Alert vs Bay Alarm Medical – Bay Alarm Medical offers month-to-month pricing. Can Life Alert compare?
  • Life Alert vs GreatCall – Can an all-in-one cellular alert stand up to Life Alert options?
  • Life Alert vs LifeStation – Each offers wearable, waterproof personal alert systems. But which one is the best deal?
  • Life Alert vs Medical Alert – Each of these companies has its strengths, which one is right for you?
  • Life Alert vs Medical Guardian – With customer friendly policies and pricing, Medical Guardian is a clear winner. But what about the equipment?
  • Life Alert vs Philips Lifeline – Both have upfront fees, are they worth it? See the comparison.
  • Life Alert vs MobileHelp – We take a look at two well-known brands. Pricing and equipment vary widely.



  • LifeStation vs Life Alert – A look at two similar companies in the way of alert systems, but their pricing and payment options are very different.
  • LifeStation vs MobileHelp – Each has similar pricing, but when you compare alert system options, there is one company that has more to offer.

Medical Alert

  • Medical Alert vs Life Alert – The differences between these two medical alert companies is in pricing and contracts. Be sure to read the fine print!

Medical Care Alert

Medical Guardian


  • MobileHelp vs Bay Alarm Medical – Two top brands who both provide in-home and cellular medical alert options. See how they compare.
  • MobileHelp vs GreatCall – See how MobileHelp and GreatCall compare, both nationally recognized brands providing cellular alert options.
  • MobileHelp vs Life Alert – Can Life Alert compete with the variety of options offered by MobileHelp? Find out in this comparison.
  • MobileHelp vs LifeStation – MobileHelp or LifeStation? See which one our editors chose.
  • MobileHelp vs Medical Guardian – MobileHelp and Medical Guardian offer similar equipment and options. They both even have a unique smart watch- which one fits in your budget?

Philips Lifeline



  • Was this Helpful ?
  • yes   no